Judgingbythecover

The Reading Room

judgingby_thecover

πŸ“š Welcome to The Reading Room by Judging by the Cover! A free community for readers who love talking books as much as reading them. Think reading journals, honest opinions, TBR recommendations, author interviews, and the occasional unpopular take. Pull up a chair. There's a seat for everyone here. πŸ–€ Every genre. Every reader. Always free.

The Dust Jacket

2025 Favorites

Judgingbythecover

The Reading Room

judgingby_thecover

πŸ“š Welcome to The Reading Room by Judging by the Cover! A free community for readers who love talking books as much as reading them. Think reading journals, honest opinions, TBR recommendations, author interviews, and the occasional unpopular take. Pull up a chair. There's a seat for everyone here. πŸ–€ Every genre. Every reader. Always free.

The Dust Jacket

2025 Favorites

Bookshelf

Welcome Back to The Reading Room πŸ“šπŸ–€

November has always been my favorite of the ’ber months. πŸ‚

There's something about this time of year that makes me want to slow down a little. The weather FINALLY starts cooling off here in South Carolina, there's good food, even better company, and everything just feels a little cozier. It's usually a quieter month for me, and honestly? I love that.

But lately, I've also been thinking a lot about community.

A little while ago, I received some pretty insanely hateful comments on YouTube. And while I know putting yourself on the internet means opening yourself up to criticism, there's a big difference between disagreeing with someone's opinion about a book and being downright cruel.

When I shared what happened on Instagram, I was absolutely overwhelmed by the love and support I received. People took time out of their days to send kind messages, share their own experiences, and remind me why I started talking about books on the internet in the first place.

And THAT is what I've been thinking about.

Because at the end of the day, I don't want to just recommend books. I want to build a space where people genuinely enjoy talking about them. Where we can have wildly different opinions about the same story and still have a fantastic conversation. Where we celebrate each other's reading wins, help each other through reading slumps, and enthusiastically convince complete strangers to add another 15 books to their TBRs. πŸ˜‚

That's what I want The Reading Room to be.

I've been a little quiet here lately, but I've also been rethinking what I want this space to look like moving forward. And I've realized I don't want Bindery to be just another place where I share content you can already find on Instagram or YouTube.

I want it to feel like an actual community. A place where we can pull up a chair, grab our favorite drink, and dish about BOOKS. All the books. Across every genre.

So here's what you can expect moving forward:

πŸ“– The Reading Journal: More candid updates about what I'm reading, what I'm loving, what's disappointing me, and everything in between. Think less polished review and more chatting with a friend.

πŸ’¬ Between the Pages: Bookish discussions, unpopular opinions, reading habits, trope debates, and all those questions that deserve more than a quick Instagram comment.

πŸ“š The TBR Table: A place to swap recommendations, discover hidden gems, and help each other figure out what to read next.

πŸŽ™οΈ Beyond the Episode: I'll still share some of my YouTube videos and author interviews here, but I want to take those conversations even further. Let's discuss the books, the authors, and the ideas that stick with us long after the episode ends.

β˜• The Reading Room Roundtable: Monthly check-ins where we can share our favorite reads, biggest surprises, reading plans, and whatever else is happening in our bookish lives.

And here's the most important part: This community will ALWAYS be free. No paywalls, no pressure, and absolutely no reading requirements.

Whether you read 200 books a year or you're struggling to finish your first, whether you're a fantasy fanatic, a romance lover, a horror enthusiast, or someone who reads a little bit of everything, you belong here.

I want this to be a place where we can disagree without being disrespectful, get excited about the stories we love, and remember that reading is supposed to be FUN.

So, consider this our official welcome back to The Reading Room. πŸ–€

Let's start with a little catch-up: What are you reading right now, and how has your reading year been treating you?

I want to hear ALL about it. The five-star favorites, the disappointing reads, the unexpected discoveries, and everything in between.

I'm so glad you're here. πŸ–€

The Books Nobody Is Talking About (But Should Be)

Can we PLEASE talk about books that aren't currently dominating BookTok and Bookstagram? Because I swear, sometimes it feels like we're all being recommended the same 20 books on repeat. πŸ˜‚

Don't get me wrong. I love discovering a fantastic new release as much as the next reader. But somewhere along the way, I think we've forgotten that books don't have an expiration date. A book published five years ago doesn't suddenly become less worth reading because it isn't trending anymore, and I find it genuinely frustrating that social media seems to reward posts about whatever is currently popular while giving backlist books considerably less attention.

It's actually one of the reasons I've made a pretty big decision about my reading life in 2027. I'm significantly cutting back on ARCs.

I've spent the last couple of years reading a LOT of advance copies, and while I'm incredibly grateful for those opportunities, I've realized how much of my reading time has become centered around what's coming out next.

I'll absolutely still read ARCs, but nowhere near the volume I have been. In 2027, I'm focusing on MY OWN SHELVES. The books I've purchased, collected, and genuinely wanted to read but somehow keep pushing aside for the next shiny release, and today, I want to share three books I wish more people were talking about.

🏚️ The House That Feeds by Maria Tureaud

For readers who loved The Reformatory and want more historical horror. This is the kind of horror that stays with me because the most terrifying things aren't necessarily supernatural...they're PEOPLE.

There's mythology-inspired magical realism woven throughout, but what makes this story so unsettling is the very human cruelty at its center. If you love historical horror that has something meaningful to say beneath its unsettling atmosphere, please put this on your radar.

🌹 The Gilded Rose by Joanna Shupe

For anyone who loves a spicy historical romance with incredible banter.

A historical Beauty and the Beast retelling?! SAY LESS. The chemistry, the banter, the tension. I was completely invested.

I literally read this book in ONE sitting, which should tell you everything you need to know about how much fun I had. Sometimes I want a book that challenges everything I believe about humanity. Sometimes I want an addictive romance that makes me forget to check the clock. This delivered the latter beautifully.

πŸ—‘οΈ The Enemy's Daughter by Melissa Poett

For readers who love YA fantasy romance with actual stakes.

A Tristan and Isolde retelling set in a dystopian society, with two people caught on opposite sides of a brutal conflict. The forbidden romance, the longing, the betrayals, the morally complicated choices. THIS is what I want from a retelling. The worldbuilding and conflict never felt like an afterthought to the romance. It's YA, but the story doesn't shy away from difficult decisions or the consequences of war.

I genuinely wish more readers would give this one a chance.

Now it's YOUR turn. πŸ‘€

I want to turn this comment section into a little treasure trove of overlooked books.

The rules are simple:

  • πŸ“š Recommend ONE book you think deserves a much bigger audience.

  • πŸ’¬ Tell us WHY you loved it. Give us the genre, the vibes, or the reason you still think about it.

  • πŸ”Ž Then scroll through the comments and find one recommendation you'd never have discovered otherwise.

  • Bonus points if it's a backlist book!

Let's give some love to the books that deserve a second life on our shelves and in our conversations. πŸ–€

πŸ“– What's on My Nightstand? November Edition

It's getting dark at 5 p.m., which apparently means my reading personality has undergone its annual transformation. πŸ˜‚

There's something about this time of year that makes me crave darker, denser books. As the days get shorter and I settle into my end-of-year hibernation, I want complicated fantasy worlds, twisty thrillers, and stories I can completely lose myself in. Throw in a dash of romance, and I'm a happy girl.

Judging by my current reads, I'm fully embracing the seasonal shift.

πŸ”ͺ Before I Disappear by Cate Quinn

This one comes out TOMORROW, and I am already on the edge of my seat.

April is exactly the kind of character I love. She's a criminologist with brains, secrets, and enough going on beneath the surface to make me suspicious of just about everything. Naturally, I've already developed several theories about where this story is headed.

But this is Cate Quinn we're talking about. I KNOW better than to get too comfortable with my predictions. πŸ˜‚

βš”οΈ The Wolves of War by John Gwynne

Listen, I am a John Gwynne fangirl through and through. The Bloodsworn trilogy remains one of my favorite fantasy series EVER, so to say my expectations for this book are high would be a massive understatement.

The Slavic mythology?! Witches, wolves, fae, and multiple POVs?! My fantasy-loving brain is spinning, but in the BEST possible way. I'm trying not to compare everything to Bloodsworn, but let's be realistic. That's going to be a challenge.

πŸ§‚ Salt: A World History by Mark Kurlansky

I am NERDING OUT over this book. Did you know the word salary is connected to the Latin word for salt and its historical value? Because I didn't, and now everyone in my household gets to hear about it. πŸ˜‚

My kids are probably getting SO tired of the random salt facts I've been sharing, but I genuinely cannot help myself.

This is exactly what I love about nonfiction. Give me a seemingly ordinary subject and show me how it shaped the world, and I will happily become the most annoying person at the dinner table.

🎧 On Audio: Tyrant Lizard Queen by Riley Black

This might be my favorite kind of nonfiction: the kind that tricks me into learning something. We're following a T. rex from hatching through adulthood, and instead of feeling like I'm listening to a science lecture, I'm getting completely immersed in a STORY.

Meanwhile, I'm absorbing all these fascinating facts about prehistoric life without even realizing how much I'm learning. More narrative nonfiction like this, PLEASE.

A little reading confession...

I've also been getting MUCH more comfortable with DNFing books lately. I DNF'd THREE audiobooks last week. Three! Not necessarily because they were bad books. I just kept zoning out. I'd realize I hadn't absorbed anything from the last ten minutes, rewind, and then promptly lose interest again.

For me, that's a pretty big red flag. Sometimes it's the book, but sometimes it's simply my mood. And I've gotten a lot better at recognizing the difference. Here's the thing...I don't HAVE to read or listen to any book. I GET to choose what I spend my time reading.

Woohoo, free will! πŸ˜‚

There are far too many books I'm genuinely excited about to force myself through something that isn't working for me right now. Maybe I'll come back to those audiobooks in a few months. Maybe I won't. I'm perfectly fine with either outcome.

I think that's where my reading life is heading as we close out 2026. Less obligation, more instinct. Darker stories, complicated characters, fascinating nonfiction, and absolutely no guilt about putting something down.

Now I'm curious about your reading life lately. πŸ–€

Are your reading tastes shifting with the seasons? And have you gotten more comfortable DNFing books, or are you someone who HAS to finish what you start?

Pull up a chair. I want to hear what's happening on your nightstand. πŸ“š

πŸ“š The TBR Table: November Edition πŸ‚

It's Nonfiction November, I have a fantasy trilogy to finish before the end of the year, and my TBR is already looking a little ambitious. πŸ˜‚

Welcome to The TBR Table, where we share what we're hoping to read, swap recommendations, and inevitably convince each other to add another 47 books to our already ridiculous TBRs.

Here's what I'm hoping to pick up this month!

πŸ§‚ Salt: A World History by Mark Kurlansky: It's Nonfiction November! And what better way to participate than reading an entire book about SALT? πŸ˜‚ I'm genuinely fascinated by the idea of exploring world history through something we use every single day.

βš”οΈ Empire by Sabaa Tahir: I've been wanting to dive back into Sabaa Tahir's storytelling, and I'm ready for some immersive fantasy!

πŸ‘‘ Splintered Kingdom by Gretchen Powell Fox: I am DETERMINED to finish this trilogy before the end of 2026. Nothing like an approaching deadline to motivate me to tackle a series finale!

πŸ¦– Tyrant Lizard Queen by Riley Black: Narrative nonfiction that follows a T. rex from hatching through adulthood, blending the latest paleontological discoveries with immersive storytelling. A dinosaur's entire life told almost like a novel?! SIGN ME UP. I'm especially excited to see the softer, more surprising side of one of history's most terrifying predators.

Will I actually read all four? Your guess is as good as mine. My TBR is more of a suggestion than a legally binding agreement. πŸ˜‚ But enough about MY books. What's everyone else bringing to the table?

πŸ’¬ Your turn!

πŸ“š Share 1–3 books you're hoping to read in November in the comments. πŸ‚ Are you participating in Nonfiction November, or are you reading something completely different?

πŸ‘€ See a book on someone else's TBR that you've loved? Tell them! Maybe you'll even find a November reading buddy.

No pressure to finish everything, no judgment if your reading plans completely change, and absolutely no required reading. The only rule at The TBR Table? Make room for one more book. πŸ–€

Gothic Horror Is More Than Haunted Houses

Mention Gothic horror, and most of us immediately know the vibe. A decaying mansion. Terrible weather. A locked room. A family with approximately 400 secrets. Someone wandering down a hallway when they should absolutely be running in the opposite direction.

And yes, give me ALL of that.

But one of the reasons Gothic horror has survived for centuries is that those recognizable elements are only the surface of the genre.

Gothic horror is really good at taking something a character would rather avoid (i.e., grief, guilt, desire, family history, violence, obsession) and making it impossible to ignore.

Sometimes it does that with a ghost. Sometimes it does it with a house. And sometimes there is absolutely nothing supernatural happening.

So let's talk about what actually makes a horror novel Gothic, and why the genre can look completely different today than it did more than 250 years ago.

First: Gothic horror is OLD

The beginning of Gothic fiction is generally traced to Horace Walpole's The Castle of Otranto, published in 1764. From there, writers continued developing what we now recognize as Gothic conventions: isolated locations, threatening environments, secrets, supernatural possibilities, vulnerable characters, psychological instability, and the sense that something isn't quite right.

But here's what I find much more interesting: The genre didn't stay trapped in the castle.

  • Mary Shelley used Gothic fiction to explore creation, abandonment, and responsibility in Frankenstein.

  • Victorian Gothic gave us stories like Dracula and The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.

  • Later writers proved you didn't need an ancient European castle at all.

  • Shirley Jackson could make an American house terrifying.

  • Daphne du Maurier could make the memory of a dead woman feel almost as present as a ghost.

  • Modern Gothic writers have continued adapting those same storytelling tools to entirely different places, cultures, histories, and fears.

The scenery changed and the genre evolved with it.

Why does Gothic horror feel different from other horror?

This is probably the easiest way to understand the genre.

A lot of horror asks: What's going to happen to me? Gothic horror very often asks: What has already happened here?

That difference completely changes the reading experience. Instead of immediately introducing a threat, Gothic stories often make us investigate one.

  • Why won't anyone talk about that room?

  • Why does this family behave this way?

  • What happened to the previous owner?

  • Why does everyone in town know something our protagonist doesn't?

  • Why does this place feel WRONG?

The tension comes from slowly understanding the significance of things that were already there, which is exactly why Gothic horror and slow burns work so beautifully together.

The setting has a job

This is one of my favorite things about Gothic fiction.

You can remove a random creepy house from plenty of horror novels and replace it with another creepy house without fundamentally changing the story.

That is much harder to do with great Gothic horror. The setting is usually connected to what the book is trying to explore.

This is why you'll often hear people say that the setting in Gothic fiction feels like another character. Place has historically been central to the genre, whether that's a castle, house, wilderness, school, estate, town, or something else entirely. THAT is much more important than simply having a spooky house.

The real Gothic question: What can't these characters escape?

Here's where I think Gothic horror gets especially interesting because the answer doesn't have to be a the haunted house.

A character can be trapped:

  • By a marriage.

  • By money.

  • By social expectations.

  • By family loyalty.

  • By grief.

  • By their own mind.

  • By something their parents did.

  • By something an entire community refuses to acknowledge.

Physical isolation is one way Gothic fiction creates that suffocating feeling, but psychological and social confinement can accomplish the exact same thing.

That's also one reason the genre has been so adaptable.

Modern writers can take the basic machinery of Gothic fiction and use it to explore entirely different experiences than the writers of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries were exploring.

And yes: sometimes the monster is metaphorical

One of my favorite things about Gothic horror is that it can make you question what kind of story you're actually reading. That ambiguity gives Gothic horror an enormous amount of room to explore psychological horror alongside supernatural horror.

It's also why you don't need ghosts, vampires, or monsters for a book to feel Gothic.

Gothic horror has always reflected what people are afraid of

This might be the most interesting part of the genre's evolution. The recognizable pieces of Gothic fiction have remained remarkably durable, but writers keep finding new things to do with them.

Modern Gothic fiction can explore race, class, gender, sexuality, colonialism, family trauma, historical violence, bodily autonomy, cultural identity, and who holds power inside supposedly "safe" spaces.

So when you read something like Mexican Gothic, you're getting recognizable Gothic ingredients (e.g., an isolated house, a disturbing family, secrets, a protagonist increasingly cut off from the outside world), but they're being used to tell a story that belongs to a much more contemporary conversation.

So how do you know if you're reading Gothic horror?

I wouldn't use a trope checklist.

A book doesn't suddenly become Gothic because someone wandered into a mansion during a thunderstorm. Instead, pay attention to the relationship between character + setting + history + fear.

Ask yourself:

  • Does the setting create pressure on the characters?

  • Is there something hidden that the protagonist is slowly uncovering?

  • Does history meaningfully affect what's happening now?

  • Are the characters trapped in some way even if the door is technically unlocked?

  • Does the story prioritize atmosphere, unease, or psychological tension?

  • Is the horror connected to something deeper than simply surviving a threat?

The more of those you're answering YES to, the deeper you're getting into Gothic territory.

Okay, but where should you start?

This is where I DON'T think everyone should automatically be handed The Castle of Otranto just because it came first.

Your best entry point depends on what you already like.

  • If you want a classic: Dracula by Bram Stoker

  • If you love haunted houses: The Haunting of Hill House by Shirley Jackson

  • If you want something lush and modern: Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

  • If you love psychological tension: Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier

  • If you want historical Gothic horror: The Hacienda by Isabel CaΓ±as

There isn't one version of Gothic horror. There are haunted houses and Gothic romances. Southern Gothic and psychological Gothic. Historical Gothic and contemporary Gothic. Monsters, ghosts, family secrets, unreliable narrators, isolated communities, and books where you finish the last page still wondering exactly what was real.

That's probably why we're still reading it more than 250 years later. The house was never really the point...it's what the author makes us confront once we're trapped inside.

If you want more recommendations, I have a full Gothic Horror Genre Guide breaking down the genre even further and helping you find the right Gothic read for you.

QOTD: What gets you every time in Gothic horror? Is it the atmosphere, the setting, family secrets, unreliable narrators, or that creeping feeling that something is very, very wrong?