πŸ“– Two Books That Completely Surprised Me

You know what's better than picking up a book you're convinced you're going to love? Picking up a book with relatively few expectations and having it completely knock you off your feet.

I've had TWO of those experiences recently, and they're a good reminder of why I love reading across so many genres. Both are fantasy. Both have complicated characters, political and societal tensions, and a little romance. But they surprised me for very different reasons.

image

βš”οΈ Defy the Dusk by Danielle L. Jensen

First, can we PLEASE stop calling every fantasy book with a romantic subplot written by a woman romantasy? Defy the Dusk is post-apocalyptic fantasy! Yes, there's an enemies-to-lovers romance, but reducing this book to its romantic elements does such a disservice to everything Danielle L. Jensen has built.

The worldbuilding is expansive, but it's the ideological conflicts that really impressed me. The tensions between the Dawnriders and Feralists, the divide between magic users and the nullborn, and the question of whether survival means running away or standing your ground all create a world where nobody has entirely clean hands.

Lirien and Vox were particularly fascinating to me because their motivations aren't nearly as straightforward as they initially appear.

Lirien is wrestling with the consequences of being the Worldbreaker, searching for atonement while trying to preserve people's freedom to choose their own futures. Vox is driven by the desire to avenge his family, but he also convinces himself that his leadership is about building a better world.

Both believe they're fighting for something greater than themselves. Both are willing to manipulate others to achieve it, and the exploration of propaganda! I loved how Jensen dove into the way competing groups use narratives to justify their authority and maintain power.

The romance is interesting precisely because Lirien and Vox don't suddenly abandon their convictions the moment attraction enters the picture. They spend much of the book working against each other, and their relationship has to contend with the very real consequences of their choices.

I wasn't entirely sold on Vox's initial decision to spare Lirien, but once the story found its footing, I was invested. Also, can we appreciate having fantasy protagonists who are 29 and 39? MORE OF THIS, PLEASE.

For longtime Jensen readers, there are some particularly intriguing connections to her earlier work. I may or may not have pulled out my Bridge Kingdom map while reading. πŸ‘€ Between the action, moral complexity, character development, and that VERY Danielle L. Jensen ending, I'm already impatient for the second book.

image

πŸ•―οΈ The Trial of Magdalena Overmorrow by CaitrΓ­ona Moran

One of my favorite books of 2026. Yes, I'm saying it. This is the kind of historical fantasy that reminds me why I love character-driven stories.

Magdalena is a scholar and healer living in a world where a woman's knowledge, independence, and willingness to challenge authority can make her dangerous in the eyes of those who hold power, and I LOVED her.

She's intelligent, capable, witty, and unwilling to make herself smaller simply because the world expects her to.

I also loved how much this story made me think. Through Magdalena's witchcraft trial, the book explores religious oppression, institutional control, and women's autonomy in ways that feel both historically grounded and uncomfortably relevant.

The magic is understated, the medieval-inspired world feels lived in, and the supporting characters bring a complexity that makes the political and personal stakes even more compelling.

There's also a slow-burn romance, but I appreciated that it never overshadowed Magdalena's own story. Her intelligence, choices, and fight for autonomy remain firmly at the center. I was so invested in her fate that I genuinely struggled to put this book down.

My one complaint? I wasn't prepared for that cliffhanger or the realization that I would have to wait for another book. πŸ˜‚

Still, this was an easy five stars for me. I've written a full review for Grimdark Magazine, where I get much deeper into Magdalena, the worldbuilding, and why this book resonated with me so strongly. You can read it over on the Grimdark Magazine website! πŸ–€

Something I've been thinking about...

Both of these books reminded me that the fantasy stories that stay with me are the ones that make me question the characters' decisions. The ones where power, morality, and personal freedom are complicated. Where I can understand someone's motivations without necessarily agreeing with their choices.

I love a good romance. I love action. I love a beautifully constructed fantasy world, but give me a character forced to reckon with what they believe, what they're willing to sacrifice, and whether the ends really justify the means? THAT'S my kind of fantasy.

Now I want to hear from you!

πŸ“š What's the last book that genuinely surprised you?

πŸ’¬ Have you ever picked up a book expecting one thing and discovered something completely different? Do you prefer your fantasy driven by epic action or complicated characters and moral dilemmas?

I want to hear about the books you didn't expect to love but absolutely did. πŸ–€

The Reading Room

100% of affiliate revenue supports The Reading Room

Book cover
Book cover

Comments


Loading...

Other posts from The Reading Room you might like